Seizure in supratentorial meningioma

Patients with supratentorial meningioma frequently suffer from seizures.

It remains unclear whether prophylactic preoperative anticonvulsant treatment is worthwhile. Furthermore, it is not clear which patients are likely to experience seizures in the course of the disease. In recent years, many studies and meta-analyses addressed this question with particular contradictory results.

Baumgarten et al. from the Department of Neurosurgery, University Hospital, Goethe University Frankfurt, Germany aimed to identify the most important risk factors for seizures in patients with meningiomas.

For the search terms “meningioma and seizure”, “meningioma and epilepsy”, and “Simpson and seizure” Medline query identified 865 articles. After applying inclusion and exclusion criteria, 20 papers were chosen for further study. The papers were analyzed for all risk factors for pre- and postoperative risk factors for seizures.

Preoperative seizures were mostly associated with extensive brain edema, localization, and bigger tumor size. Even though data were sometimes very contradictory, higher postoperative seizure rate in patients with meningioma was associated with distinct localizations, preoperative seizures, tumor size, brain edema, extent of resection, tumor recurrence, and new neurological deficits. There were no randomized trials showing a prophylactic effect of anticonvulsant drugs.

There are relevant risk factors for seizures in patients with meningioma. There is the need for a double blind randomized trial for the prophylactic use of antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) ¹⁾.

Englot et al performed a systematic review of PubMed for manuscripts published between January 1980 and September 2014, examining rates of pre- and postoperative seizures in supratentorial meningioma, and evaluating potential predictors of seizures with separate meta-analyses.

The authors identified 39 observational case series for inclusion in the study, but no controlled trials. Preoperative seizures were observed in 29.2% of 4709 patients with supratentorial meningioma, and were significantly predicted by male sex (OR 1.74, 95% CI 1.30-2.34); an absence of headache (OR 1.77, 95% CI 1.04-3.25); peritumoral edema (OR 7.48, 95% CI 6.13-9.47); and non-skull base location (OR 1.77, 95% CI 1.04-3.25). After surgery, seizure freedom was achieved in 69.3% of 703 patients with preoperative epilepsy, and was more than twice as likely in those without peritumoral edema, although an insufficient number of studies were available for formal meta-analysis of this association. Of 1085 individuals without preoperative epilepsy who underwent resection, new postoperative seizures were seen in 12.3% of patients. No difference in the rate of new postoperative seizures was observed with or without perioperative prophylactic anticonvulsants.

Seizures are common in supratentorial meningioma, particularly in tumors associated with brain edema, and seizure freedom is a critical treatment goal. Favorable seizure control can be achieved with resection, but evidence does not support routine use of prophylactic anticonvulsants in patients without seizures. Limitations associated with systematic review and meta-analysis should be considered when interpreting these results ²⁾.

Englot et al systematically reviewed the published literature on seizure freedom following the resection of supratentorial CCMs in patients presenting with seizures. Seizure outcomes were stratified across 12 potential prognostic variables. A total of 1226 patients with supratentorial CCMs causing seizures were identified across 31 predominantly retrospective studies; 361 patients had medically refractory epilepsy.

Seventy-five percent of the patients were seizure free after microsurgical lesion removal, whereas 25% continued to have seizures. All patients had had preoperative seizures and > 6 months of postoperative follow-up. Modifiable predictors of postoperative seizure freedom included gross-total resection (OR 36.6, 95% CI 8.5-157.5) and surgery within 1 year of symptom onset (OR 1.83, 95% CI 1.30-2.58). Additional prognostic indicators of a favorable outcome were a CCM size < 1.5 cm (OR 15.4, 95% CI 5.2-45.4), the absence of multiple CCMs (OR 2.02, 95% CI 1.13-3.60), medically controlled seizures (OR 2.38, 95% CI 1.29-4.39), and the lack of secondarily generalized seizures (OR 3.33, 95% CI 2.09-5.30). Other factors, including extended resection of the hemosiderin ring, were not significantly predictive.

In the surgical treatment of supratentorial CCMs, gross-total resection and early operative intervention may improve seizure outcome. While surgery should not be considered the first-line treatment for CCM-related epilepsy, it is important to understand the variables associated with seizure freedom in CCM resection given the considerable morbidity and diminished quality of life associated with epilepsy ³⁾.

A MEDLINE search of the literature (1979-2010) was performed. Comparisons were made for patient and tumor characteristics as well as success of repair, morbidity, and seizure outcome. Statistical analyses of categorical variables were undertaken using chi-square and Fisher exact tests.

Nineteen studies, involving 698 patients, were included. There were no significant differences in the extent of resection, perioperative mortality, or recurrence between the AED and no-AED cohorts. Likewise, there were no significant differences in the incidence of early or late seizures between the cohorts.

The results of this systematic analysis supports the conclusion that the prophylactic administration of anticonvulsants during resection of supratentorial meningiomas provides no benefit in the prevention of either early or late postoperative seizures. Despite their traditional role in this patient population, the routine use of AEDs should be carefully reconsidered ⁴⁾.

A retrospective chart review of 1033 subjects undergoing resection of supratentorial meningioma at the author's institution (1991-2014). Multivariate regression was used to identify variables significantly associated with pre- and postoperative seizures.

Preoperative seizures occurred in 234 (22.7%) subjects. At 5 years postoperative, probability of seizure freedom was 89.9% among subjects without preoperative seizures and 62.2% with preoperative seizures. Multivariate analysis identified the following predictors of preoperative seizures: presence of  ≥1 cm peritumoral edema (odds ratio [OR]: 4.45, 2.55-8.50), nonskull base tumor location (OR: 2.13, 1.26-3.67), greater age (OR per unit increase: 1.03, 1.01-1.05), while presenting symptom of headache (OR: 0.50, 0.29-0.84) or cranial nerve deficit (OR: 0.36, 0.17-0.71) decreased odds of preoperative seizures. Postoperative seizures after discharge were associated with preoperative seizures (OR: 5.70, 2.57-13.13), in-hospital seizure (OR: 4.31, 1.28-13.67), and among patients without preoperative seizure, occurrence of medical or surgical complications (OR 3.39, 1.09-9.48). Perioperative anti-epileptic drug use was not associated with decreased incidence of postoperative seizures.

Nonskull base supratentorial meningiomas with surrounding edema have the highest risk for preoperative seizure. Long-term follow-up showing persistent seizures in meningioma patients with preoperative seizures raises the possibility that these patients may benefit from electrocorticographic mapping of adjacent cortex and resection of noneloquent, epileptically active cortex ⁵⁾.

Adult patients who underwent primary resection of a supratentorial World Health Organization grade I meningioma at a single institution between 1996 and 2006 were retrospectively reviewed. Multivariate logistical regression analyses were used to identify associations with preoperative seizures, and multivariate proportional hazards regression analyses were used to identify associations with prolonged seizure control after surgical resection.

Of the 626 patients in this series, 84 (13%) presented with seizures. The factors independently associated with preoperative seizures were Karnofsky performance score ≤ 80 (P< 0.0001), absence of headaches (P = 0.0006), and vasogenic edema (P = 0.007). At 48 months postoperatively, 90% were Engel class I, 3% were class II, 0 were class III, and 7% were class IV. The factors independently associated with decreased seizure control after surgical resection were uncontrolled preoperative seizures (P = 0.04), parasagittal tumors (P = 0.03), and tumors along the sphenoid wing (P = 0.05). The association between seizure recurrence and tumor recurrence trended toward but did not achieve statistical significance (P = 0.11).

With the widespread availability of various neuroimaging modalities, there will be increased detection of intracranial meningiomas. The identification and consideration of factors associated with seizure onset and prolonged seizure control may help guide treatment strategies aimed at improving the quality of life for patients with meningiomas ⁶⁾.