Table of Contents

Surgical volume in neurosurgery

Surgical Volume in Endoscopic Transsphenoidal Surgery for Pituitary Neuroendocrine Tumors (PitNETs)

Definition and Importance of Surgical Volume

Surgical volume refers to the number of transsphenoidal surgeries (TSS) performed annually at a given institution or by an individual surgeon. It is a critical factor in determining surgical success, complication rates, and overall patient outcomes.

High-volume centers (HVCs) have been consistently associated with:


Impact of Surgical Volume on Outcomes

Factor High-Volume Centers (HVC) Low-Volume Centers (LVC)
Tumor Resection Rate Higher (More complete resections) Lower (Higher residual tumor rate)
Complication Rate Lower (<20%) Higher (>25%)
Endocrine Remission Rate Improved in functioning PitNETs Lower remission rates
Postoperative CSF Leak Reduced (<5-10%) Increased (>10%)
Hypopituitarism Less frequent More common

Why Does Surgical Volume Matter?


Defining High-Volume Centers (HVCs) in Pituitary Surgery

The definition of a high-volume center varies, but international standards suggest:

'🔹 In Spain (TESSPAIN Study, 2025):' High-volume centers were defined as those performing >25 TSS/year or having national expertise, but this threshold may underestimate the benefits of very high-volume centers.


Evidence Supporting Centralization of Pituitary Surgery

Several studies confirm better outcomes in high-volume centers:


Conclusion & Recommendations

Retrospective multicenter observational studies

TESSPAIN evaluates TSS outcomes in Spanish centers to assess the influence of surgical volume and specialized neurosurgery teams on success and complication rates.

A retrospective, nationwide study of Spanish centers performing TSS between January 2018 and December 2022. Centers were classified as high-volume centers (HV) [n=11, defined as centers with recognized expertise in Spain or those performing more than 25 TSS/year] or non-HV. Data collection included surgical success rates, complications, and pituitary adenoma resectability (R-PA). Additional analyses evaluated the impact of dedicated neurosurgical teams (DNT) within HV centers.

2815 TSS from 29 Spanish centers were included (1421 NSPA, 436 GH-secreting, 323 Cushing's disease, 127 PRL-secreting, and 25 TSH-secreting PA). The overall success rate was 50.5%, 76.8% for R-PA. HV centers had a higher overall success rate (53.1 vs. 47.7%; p=0.03). Better TSS outcomes for NSPA accounted for this difference. The overall TSS complication rate was 22.1%, which was higher for NSPA than for SPA (25.0 vs. 17.7%). The overall complication rate of TSS for PA was significantly higher in non-HV centers than in HV centers (24 vs 20.4.0; p <0.01). Centers with a DNT showed a trend to higher success rate in R-PA, while having a lower overall incidence of complications in TSS for PA than HV centers without a DNT (18.5 vs. 23.0; p=0.058), mainly reducing the rate of permanent ADH deficiency in all TSS for PA (2.7 vs. 8.4%; p<0.001).

Higher surgical volume and DNT are associated with improved TSS outcomes for PA in Spain. The results support the recommendation of concentrating pituitary surgery in a reduced number of centers of expertise in the country to improve the success rate and reduce complications, mainly postoperative ADH deficiency 1)

1)
Paja M, Soto A, Hanzu FA, Guerrero-Pérez F, Cámara R, Moure D, Gálvez Á, Simó-Servat A, Villar-Taibo R, Calatayud M, Vicente A, Recio-Córdova JM, Serra G, Martín Rojas-Marcos P, Parra-Ramírez P, Araujo-Castro M, Librizzi S, Irigaray A, Ollero D, Aznar S, Muñoz F, Aulinas A, González-Fernández L, García-Centeno R, Egaña N, González-Vidal T, Menéndez E, Delgado AM, Abarca J, Sottile J, Picó AM, Novo C, Ortiz I, Tenorio C, de León R, de Pablos-Velasco P, Crespo C, Peñalver D, Díaz-Soto G, Puig-Domingo M, Biagetti B. Outcomes of transsphenoidal surgery for pituitary adenomas in Spain: a retrospective multicenter study. Front Endocrinol (Lausanne). 2025 Feb 21;16:1529418. doi: 10.3389/fendo.2025.1529418. PMID: 40060376; PMCID: PMC11886961.