Protective Effect of Resveratrol Against Intracranial Aneurysm Rupture in Mice
. J Neurosci Res. 2025 Jun;103(6):e70059. doi:10.1002/jnr.70059. PMID: 40546125.Evidence Level | Findings |
---|---|
Animal studies | ↓ Aneurysm formation, ↓ inflammation, ↓ MMPs, ↓ NF‑κB activity |
SAH rodent models | ↓ Brain edema and injury, improved barrier integrity |
Human data | No trials in aneurysms; low bioavailability limits systemic benefit |
Type of study:: In vivo animal study (murine intracranial aneurysm model) First author:: Dang et al. Author affiliations::
Journal:: Journal of Neuroscience Research Purpose:: To evaluate whether dietary resveratrol prevents formation or rupture of intracranial aneurysms via anti‑inflammatory mechanisms. Conclusions::
Citation:: 1)
1. Model limitations The elastase + DOCA‑salt murine model poorly reflects human aneurysm pathophysiology, lacking hemodynamic fidelity. No histological validation of aneurysm similarity or wall integrity is presented.
2. Statistical fragility Sample size is small (N not disclosed), likely underpowered. The significant reduction in rupture risk may result from chance due to low event counts. No power analysis provided.
3. Incomplete inflammatory profiling Only mRNA (not protein) levels of Sirt1, Nfkb1, and Tnf were analyzed. No IHC, ELISA, or time-course experiments to demonstrate functional effects or causality.
4. Intervention timing Resveratrol was administered preventively—3 weeks before aneurysm induction. This limits translational relevance as human patients typically present after aneurysm formation.
5. Lacking pharmacokinetics/pharmacodynamics No measurement of serum/tissue levels of resveratrol. Effective concentrations in cerebral vasculature remain speculative.
6. Uncontrolled confounders No report of blood pressure differences between groups, despite using a DOCA‑salt model of induced hypertension.
7. Limited novelty Anti-inflammatory vascular effects of resveratrol are well-documented. This work offers incremental rather than groundbreaking insight.
Flawed design and lack of translational rigor render the study hypothesis-generating at best. The purported protective role of resveratrol lacks mechanistic depth and clinical relevance.
Resveratrol may reduce rupture risk in an artificial murine model, but this does not justify clinical application. Future research must explore post-formation interventions, robust models, and PK/PD validation.
Encouraging data in mice—yet insufficient to warrant human trials.
3/10 – Preliminary and biologically plausible, but weak in methodology and translational relevance.
Protective Effect of Resveratrol Against Intracranial Aneurysm Rupture in Mice
. J Neurosci Res. 2025 Jun;103(6):e70059. doi:10.1002/jnr.70059. PMID: 40546125.