Controversial. Some authors feel that most tumors (except germinomas, which are best treated with XRT) are amenable to open resection. Others feel that resection should be limited to ā 25% of tumors which area:
1. radioresistance (e.g. malignant nongerminoma GCTs): 35ā50% of pineal region tumors (larger numbers occur in series not limited to pediatric patients)
2. benign (e.g. meningioma, teratomasā¦)
3. well-encapsulated
4. NB: malignant germ cell tumors should be without evidence of metastases (those with metastases do not benefit from surgery on the primary tumor)
5. pineocytoma: recommendation is for surgical excision + SRS for any residual