In a secondary analysis of RCT comparing diagnostic & management decisions Janny Mathieu et al. from:
published in Scientific Reports to assess agreement in diagnosis and management between chiropractors and neurosurgeons for patients referred for Low back pain consultation. Diagnostic concordance was moderate (74.7%, κ = 0.51), management concordance strong (82%), suggesting chiropractors are competent for triage of non‑surgical low back pain, potentially easing surgical consult load 1)
Critical review:
- Strengths:
- Limitations:
Final verdict (score: 6/10)
This well‑performed concordance study supports the potential role of chiropractors in neurosurgery triage pathways. However, moderate diagnostic agreement and tertiary clinic setting limits full endorsement. More prospective trials linking triage accuracy to patient‑centered outcomes are needed.
Takeaway for neurosurgeons: Chiropractors demonstrate acceptable diagnostic and strong management alignment with neurosurgeons. They may effectively triage non‑surgical low back pain, helping reduce surgical wait times—but diagnostic nuance remains essential.
Bottom line: Chiropractor‑based triage shows promise for improving low back pain pathways, yet definitive benefit requires prospective validation with patient outcomes.
Publication date: July 2, 2025 Corresponding author: janny.mathieu@uqtr.ca