===== Meaningful (Scientific Definition) ===== **Meaningful** refers to research results, innovations, or interventions that have clear biological, clinical, or translational significance beyond mere technical success. ==== Characteristics of Meaningful Outcomes ==== * Demonstrates functional or therapeutic impact * Solves a defined clinical or scientific problem * Offers improvement over existing alternatives * Relevance is supported by context and application ==== Non-Examples ==== * Delivery of fluorescent proteins without therapeutic intent * Engineering complexity without biological justification * In vivo "proofs" that lack disease relevance ==== Example ==== A gene therapy that restores motor function in a Parkinson’s model is meaningful. Delivering Cas9 to random brain cells without editing or phenotype data is not.