Critical Review: Neurocirugía (English Edition) [Neurosurgery Wiki]

This page is read only. You can view the source, but not change it. Ask your administrator if you think this is wrong.
====== Critical Review: Neurocirugía (English Edition) ======

**Journal Title:** Neurocirugía (English Edition)  
**Publisher:** Elsevier España / Sociedad Española de Neurocirugía (SENEC)  
**Language:** Bilingual (Spanish & English)  
**Frequency:** Bimonthly  
**ISSN:** 1130-1473  
**Website:** https://www.revistaneurocirugia.com/en  

===== 🔍 Scope and Aims =====
* Covers original clinical and experimental research in neurosurgery.
* Accepts expert reviews, technical notes, clinical guidelines, and illustrative cases.
* Prioritizes issues relevant to Spanish-speaking neurosurgical practice.
* Double-blinded peer review system.
* Indexed in Medline, Scopus, JCR, SJR, SNIP.

===== 📈 Impact and Metrics (2024) =====
^ Metric                     ^ Value      ^ Interpretation                      ^
| Impact Factor (JCR)        | 0.8         | Low international influence         |
| CiteScore (Scopus)         | 1.4         | Moderate for regional journals      |
| SJR                        | 0.286 (Q3)  | Third quartile                      |
| SNIP                       | 0.424       | Below global average                |
| h-index                    | 26          | Modest historical citation impact   |
| Time to acceptance         | ~4 months   | Moderate                            |
| Time to publication        | ~7 months   | Could delay time-sensitive results  |

===== ✅ Strengths =====
  * **Bilingual publication** increases accessibility.
  * **Indexed in major databases**, ensuring discoverability.
  * **Solid peer-review process**, following COPE standards.
  * **National clinical relevance** with practical impact on Spanish neurosurgical care.
  * **Platform for consensus documents and national guidelines.**

===== ⚠️ Limitations =====
  * **Low citation impact** compared to top-tier journals.
  * **Geographically limited scope**—primarily cited within Spain or Latin America.
  * **Moderate publication delays**, which can affect the relevance of fast-moving topics.
  * **Limited influence on global neurosurgical discourse.**

===== 🧭 Comparative Context =====
^ Journal                              ^ Impact Factor ^ SJR   ^ Global Standing       ^
| Journal of Neurosurgery              | ~4.1          | ~1.5  | High                   |
| Neurosurgery (LWW)                  | ~3.9          | ~1.3  | High                   |
| World Neurosurgery                   | ~2.1          | ~0.8  | Moderate-High          |
| Neurocirugía (English Edition)       | ~0.8          | 0.286 | Regionally important   |

===== 📝 Recommendations =====
  * Ideal for neurosurgeons publishing clinical experiences or national-level content in Spain or Latin America.
  * Less appropriate for authors seeking high international impact or visibility.
  * Recommended as a secondary submission option when broader journals are unavailable or inappropriate.

===== 🧠 Final Appraisal =====
**Neurocirugía** is a respectable, bilingual neurosurgery journal with solid editorial standards and regional influence. It serves as a crucial platform for Spanish-speaking neurosurgeons and national consensus work but has limited weight in the global neurosurgical literature. Strategic use recommended based on intended audience and publication goals.