Journal of Health, Population and Nutrition: Critical Review [Neurosurgery Wiki]

This page is read only. You can view the source, but not change it. Ask your administrator if you think this is wrong.
====== Journal of Health, Population and Nutrition: Critical Review ======

===== 🧾 Journal Profile =====

  * **Title:** Journal of Health, Population and Nutrition (JHPN)
  * **Publisher:** BMC / Springer Nature
  * **Open Access:** Yes (APC-based model)
  * **Indexing:** PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, DOAJ
  * **h-index:** ~79
  * **Impact Factor (2023):** 2.4  
  * **Estimated IF (2024):** ~2.87  
  * **SJR (2024):** 0.737  
  * **SNIP (2024):** 1.045  
  * **5-Year IF:** 2.7  
  * **Categories:** Q1 in Food Science, Q2 in Public Health / Epidemiology (Scopus)

===== ✅ Strengths =====

  * **Global multidisciplinary scope:** covers public health, nutrition, maternal/child health, emerging diseases.
  * **Full open access:** all articles are freely available.
  * **Fast editorial processing:** 21 days to first decision, ~106 days to acceptance.
  * **High visibility:** over 800,000 downloads/year; strong altmetric impact.
  * **Alignment with SDGs:** >50% of 2024 articles linked to UN Sustainable Development Goals.

===== ❗ Weaknesses =====

  * **Moderate impact factor:** lower than top-tier journals in nutrition/public health.
  * **Single-blind peer review:** potential for reviewer bias.
  * **High publication cost:** ~$2,790 APC may be a barrier in resource-limited settings.
  * **Thematic restrictions:** no longer accepts Mendelian randomization studies.
  * **Editorial ambiguity:** historically based in Bangladesh, now UK-based via BMC.

===== 📊 Comparison with Peer Journals =====

^ Journal                          ^ Est. IF     ^ Access Type   ^ Peer Review Type  ^ General Remarks                          ^
| JHPN                             | ~2.87       | Open Access   | Single-blind       | Global health scope, LMIC-friendly        |
| Am. J. Clin. Nutrition           | ~7.0        | Subscription  | Single-blind       | Prestigious, clinical nutrition           |
| Crit. Rev. Food Science & Nutr.  | ~11         | Subscription  | Likely single-blind| High-level reviews in food/nutrition      |
| Annual Review of Nutrition       | ~12.6       | Subscription  | Expert commission  | Influential annual thematic reviews       |

===== 🎯 Best Suited For =====

  * Research with global health relevance.
  * Public health and nutrition topics, especially in LMIC contexts.
  * Authors needing open access with relatively fast publication.

===== 🧭 Less Suitable For =====

  * Researchers seeking top-tier citation metrics.
  * Studies in genetic epidemiology (e.g. Mendelian randomization).
  * Unfunded authors unable to cover APC fees.

===== ✅ Final Verdict =====

*Journal of Health, Population and Nutrition* is a credible, open-access journal with solid indexing, broad scope, and efficient workflows. While not among the highest-impact venues, it is a strong platform for global health research, especially from underrepresented settings.