Cuproptosis-associated LncRNA model [Neurosurgery Wiki]

This page is read only. You can view the source, but not change it. Ask your administrator if you think this is wrong.
====== Cuproptosis-associated LncRNA model ======
A cuproptosis-associated [[LncRNA]] model is a computational (often prognostic or predictive) model that uses the expression levels of long non-coding RNAs (LncRNAs) associated with cuproptosis—a recently discovered form of copper-induced cell death—to:

Predict clinical outcomes, such as overall survival in cancers like glioma or hepatocellular carcinoma.

Estimate patient response to immunotherapy or other treatment strategies.

Define molecular subtypes of tumors based on their copper metabolism susceptibility.
----

----
====== 🧨 Critical Review ======

===== Article =====
**A novel cuproptosis-associated LncRNA model predicting prognostic and immunotherapy response for glioma**  
''Discov Oncol. 2025 Jun 13;16(1):1089. doi:10.1007/s12672-025-02912-6''  
Bo Lei et al.  
PMID: [[https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40512434|40512434]]

===== ❌ 1. Title vs. Substance =====
The [[title]] promises a “novel” [[prognostic model]] and claims to predict [[immunotherapy]] response. In practice, it’s yet another **superficial LncRNA panel built from [[TCGA]] data** using recycled bioinformatics pipelines with no prospective [[validation]] or clinical applicability.

===== 🧪 2. Methodological Copy-Paste Syndrome =====
  * Uses the same **LASSO-Cox pipeline** seen in countless TCGA-based studies.
  * **No external validation** (e.g., CGGA or institutional dataset).
  * **No performance metrics** beyond p-values and Kaplan-Meier plots.
  * **No biological validation**: no functional assays, no perturbation experiments.

===== 🧫 3. Cuproptosis in Name Only =====
  * “Cuproptosis” is used as a buzzword — no measurement of copper, no FDX1/DLAT/LIAS analysis, no experimental link between selected LncRNAs and copper-induced cell death.
  * **Pure correlation without causation.**
  * Misleading terminology — this is not a **cuproptosis model**, but a **statistical cluster with cosmetic labeling**.

===== 🧠 4. Glioma Oversimplification =====
  * **No stratification by IDH status**, MGMT methylation, or histological subtype.
  * Glioblastoma and lower-grade gliomas are lumped together, ignoring key biological differences.
  * Reduces a complex disease to **spreadsheet-level pattern matching**.

===== 🧬 5. Immunotherapy Claims: Speculative and Misleading =====
  * Predicts immunotherapy response based on **immune infiltration scores** (ssGSEA, CIBERSORT) — not real-world response data.
  * No validation against **PD-L1 status**, **TMB**, or **checkpoint inhibitor trials**.
  * **Speculative inference masquerading as translational relevance.**

===== 📉 6. Ethics Approval ≠ Scientific Rigor =====
  * Institutional approval and informed consent are in place — as they should be.
  * But ethical compliance **does not equal scientific validity**.

===== 💸 7. Journal Trend: Discov Oncol and Low-Bar Pipelines =====
  * Discov Oncol has become a magnet for **template-driven, citation-chasing models** that lack mechanistic substance.
  * This paper reflects that editorial drift — **quick to publish, slow to question**.

===== 🧯 Final Verdict =====
> ❝This is not a model. It’s a statistical illusion dressed in scientific terminology, chasing citations by riding the “cuproptosis” trend without grounding in biology or relevance to clinical neuro-oncology.❞

**Recommendation**: *Reject unless mechanistic insight, external validation, and molecular stratification are provided.*


----

----


====== 🧬 What is cuproptosis? ======

Cuproptosis is a novel form of regulated cell death triggered by the accumulation of intracellular copper ions. It specifically affects mitochondrial enzymes that require lipoylated cofactors, leading to proteotoxic stress and cell death. It is mechanistically distinct from apoptosis, ferroptosis, and necroptosis.

📊 How is a cuproptosis-associated LncRNA model built?
Identification of cuproptosis-related genes: e.g., FDX1, DLAT, LIAS, etc.

Correlation analysis: LncRNAs co-expressed with these genes are identified.

Statistical filtering: Univariate and multivariate Cox regression or LASSO regression are used to select prognostically relevant LncRNAs.

Risk scoring model: Each patient receives a risk score based on the weighted expression of selected LncRNAs.

Validation: The model is tested on independent datasets (e.g., TCGA or CGGA cohorts).

🎯 Applications
Stratifying glioma patients into high-risk and low-risk groups.

Guiding personalized immunotherapy.

Revealing copper metabolism pathways relevant to tumor progression.